109,000 patients wait as new organ rules take effect Dec. 6
The first national guidelines for normothermic regional perfusion aim to boost organ supply but face criticism over the definition of death.
By Eric Collins ·

The Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network approved the first uniform national guidelines for normothermic regional perfusion on Nov. 6. The policy takes effect on Dec. 6. It standardizes a procedure that doctors use to keep organs viable after a patient is declared dead by circulatory criteria.
More than 109,000 Americans currently wait for a transplant, according to the Health Resources and Services Administration. Agency director Dr. Raymond Lynch stated that about 12 people die every day due to the shortage. He said NRP increases both the supply and the quality of available organs.
The procedure involves attaching an external pump to a donor minutes after their heart stops. The pump restores blood flow to the heart, lungs, kidneys, and liver. This prevents organ deterioration before surgeons remove them for transplant.
Critics argue the practice violates the Dead Donor Rule. This rule limits organ removal to patients who are dead by brain death or circulatory death. Dr. Lainie Friedman Ross, a bioethicist at the University of Rochester, said the procedure reverses the condition that declared the person dead.
She stated that the method takes organs from people who are no longer dead. Dr. Ross noted that circulatory death criteria prohibit attempts to reestablish circulation. NRP does exactly that by using a mechanical pump.
A separate concern involves the blood supply to the brain during the procedure. Surgeons clamp blood vessels to the head to prevent brain perfusion. Dr. Claire Morgan, a transplant surgeon on the Patient Affairs Committee, reported signs of life in cases where blood reperfused the brain. She called the incidents extremely disturbing.
The new guidelines require surgeons to cut holes in the clamped blood vessels. Lynch explained that this venting acts as a second safeguard. If the clamp fails, warm oxygenated blood drains out of the head instead of supplying the brain. The policy also recommends against using drugs that paralyze donors, which could mask movements.
Dr. Matthew DeCamp, a bioethicist at the University of Colorado, described the policy as the cart before the horse. He said the fundamental ethical issues remain unresolved. Morgan agreed, noting that many surgeons already clamp and vent vessels. She argued the new rules offer little more protection than donors previously had.






