New Federal Rules Change How Organs Are Removed After Death
HRSA approved the first national guidelines for a procedure that restarts circulation to preserve organs, a move that critics say challenges long-standing ethical standards.
By Daniela Ortega ·

The federal government has approved the first uniform national guidelines for a controversial organ recovery procedure. The new rules take effect on Dec. 6 and change how surgeons can preserve organs after a patient is declared dead.
The procedure is called normothermic regional perfusion, or NRP. It is used in hospitals after a family decides to withdraw life support because there is no hope of meaningful recovery. Doctors declare the patient dead by circulatory criteria, meaning their heart has stopped beating and circulation has ceased. Minutes after this declaration, surgeons attach an external pump to the donor. The pump restores blood flow to the heart, lungs, kidneys, and liver. This process keeps the organs from deteriorating while they are being prepared for transplant.
Dr. Raymond Lynch, the director of transplantation at the Health Resources and Services Administration, explained the goal of the new policy. The agency oversees the U.S. organ transplant system. Lynch stated that the hope with NRP is to increase both the supply and the quality of available organs. He noted that more than 109,000 Americans are currently waiting for a transplant. According to HRSA data, about 12 people die every day due to a chronic shortage of organs.
Critics argue that the procedure violates the Dead Donor Rule. This rule is considered the most important protection for potential donors. It states that surgeons may only remove organs from patients who are dead by brain death or circulatory death. Because NRP restarts circulation, opponents say it reverses the condition that made the person dead. Dr. Lainie Friedman Ross, a bioethicist at the University of Rochester, said she has a real problem with the practice. She argued that it takes organs from people who are no longer dead.
A specific concern for medical teams is what happens to the brain after the pump restarts blood flow. Surgeons typically clamp the blood vessels that supply the head to keep blood from reaching the brain. However, in some cases, blood appeared to get restored to the brain, a process known as reperfusion. Dr. Claire Morgan, a transplant surgeon on the OPTN Patient Affairs Committee, said her team has seen signs of life in NRP cases when the brain was reperfused. She described the observation as extremely disturbing.
These cases prompted the Health Resources and Services Administration to direct the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network to investigate. On Nov. 6, the OPTN board of directors approved the first phase of the new guidelines. The policy requires surgeons to do more than just clamp the blood vessels to the brain. Under the new rules, surgeons must also cut holes in the vessels. Lynch explained that clamping should stop blood flow. Cutting or venting above the clamp serves as a second safeguard. If the clamping is insufficient, the blood drains out of the head instead of supplying warm oxygenated blood to the brain.
The policy also recommends against giving donors drugs that would paralyze them. This measure is intended to prevent medications from masking any movements that might indicate activity. Critics, however, say the new safeguards are not enough. Morgan pointed out that most surgeons already clamp and vent blood vessels to the brain. She stated that she does not believe the policy creates much more protection than donors already had. She also disagreed with the decision to implement the first phase on an emergency basis before the public could weigh in.
Dr. Matthew DeCamp, a bioethicist at the University of Colorado, said the policy does not address the fundamental issue that NRP donors are not technically dead when organs are removed. He called the policy the cart before the horse, noting that the core ethical issues remain unresolved. Lynch countered that the guidelines are an important first step. He argued that the rules ensure NRP care is available while keeping the safety of the family’s loved one at the forefront. He described the procedure as life-saving care that will extend the supply and improve the quality of organs for patients.






